Skip to main content

Court throws out Dr M’s appeal over forex losses suit

PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal today dismissed Prime Minister Dr Mahathir Mohamad’s appeal to reinstate his suit to invalidate a royal commission of inquiry (RCI) report into foreign exchange losses suffered by Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) in the 1990s.
Justice Ahmadi Asnawi, who chaired a three-man panel, said the findings of the RCI are not subject to challenge.
He added that Mahathir was challenging the findings of the RCI itself, as contained in the report.
Hence, he said, the Federal Court decision on the RCI into the controversial video clip case of former lawyer VK Lingam applies to Mahathir’s case.
The Federal Court had ruled in 2011 that the findings of the RCI could not be reviewed as the commissioners had only made findings and not a decision.
Ahmadi, who sat with justices Lau Bee Lan and Has Zanah Mehat, said Section 22 of the Commissions of Enquiry Act 1950 provides wide discretion to RCIs to regulate their own affairs and procedures, including the compilation of reports and regulations for presentation to the Agong.
“We are also of the view that it is not the role of this court to tell the RCI how to run its affairs because Section 22 of the act is very wide to govern the conduct,” he said.
The panel affirmed the Dec 17, 2018 High Court decision to strike out Mahathir’s originating summons in which he sought a declaration that the RCI report on BNM’s forex trading losses is invalid, incomplete and defective as it excluded the legal documents of witnesses, notes of proceedings and written and oral submissions.
In his suit filed in December 2017, Mahathir also sought a declaration that any report by the RCI set up under the Commissions of Enquiry Act would only be legal if it had all the written statements of the witnesses who testified during proceedings as well as the notes of proceedings and submissions.
He named the RCI chairman, Mohd Sidek Hassan, its members Kamaludin Md Said, Tajuddin Atan, Saw Choo Boon, K Pushpanathanan and Yusof Ismail, as well as former prime minister Najib Razak, Cabinet members and the government as defendants in the suit.
Mahathir’s counsel, Mohamed Haniff Khatri Abdulla, earlier submitted that his client was not seeking to quash the findings of the RCI but wanted a declaration that the report would only be complete and valid if it contained the relevant documents.
However, senior federal counsel Mazlifah Ayob, appearing for the respondents, argued that if the RCI report was declared null and void, the RCI’s findings and recommendations would also be declared null and void.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Tinggalkan DAP

Tinggalkan DAP Memang tak sangka, bila dengar berita ni. Ong Kian Ming ni dah 14 tahun dalam DAP, lama sangat tu, tiba-tiba keluar mesti ada sebab berat. Dari apa yang dia cakap, isu utama dia tak puas hati keputusan parti kekal dalam kabinet. Dia rasa DAP patut keluar dulu, tekan kerajaan buat perubahan yang dijanjikan, tapi parti pilih untuk terus kekal. Bila prinsip sendiri tak sama dengan hala tuju parti, memang susah nak terus tinggal. Dia pun kata tak masuk parti lain, tak nak bertanding juga. Nampak macam bukan sebab nak lari ke tempat lain, tapi betul-betul rasa tak sehaluan dah. Bila orang yang dah lama dalam parti pun buat keputusan macam ni, mesti ada benda yang tak kena di dalam. Entah-entah ini cuma permulaan saja, belum tahu siapa lagi akan ikut jejak langkah dia selepas ni.
Post a Comment
Read more

Pilih semula BN kalau kami gagal kata Saddiq

KUALA LUMPUR: Ketua Pemuda Parti Pribumi Bersatu Malaysia (PPBM), Syed Saddiq Syed Abdul Rahman menegaskan Pakatan Harapan (PH) sanggup dibuang seandainya PH gagal memenuhi manifesto mereka selepas dipilih sebagai kerajaan dalam Pilihan Raya Umum ke-14 (PRU14). “Kalau Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad, Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin, Rafizi Ramli, Datuk Seri Mohamed Azmin Ali termasuk saya gagal menunaikan janji, buanglah kami dan pilihlah BN,” kata Syed Saddiq ketika sesi acara 'Sinar Debat bersama Exco Pemuda UMNO'. Syed Saddiq berkongsi pentas dengan Exco Pemuda UMNO, Rahman Hussin dalam forum anjuran Sinar Harian diadakan di ibu pejabatnya di Shah Alam, Selangor pada Isnin. Menurut Syed Saddiq, PH perlu diberi peluang demi masa depan yang baharu. Ujar beliau, rakyat berkuasa untuk membawa perubahan kerana walaupun negara ditadbir oleh BN lebih 60 tahun, parti itu adalah tidak sama seperti dahulu. Menurutnya, PH juga akan membebaskan media dan mana-mana kerajaan ti...
Post a Comment
Read more

RM314 Juta Tidak Diterima Kerajaan, Anthony Loke Patut Dipertanggungjawapkan

Isu penggantungan perkhidmatan MYEG dan Zetrix AI ini bukan sekadar pertikaian komersial biasa tetapi ia satu isu yang melibatkan amanah rakyat dan aliran dana negara. Dua platform ini  diwujudkan untuk memperkemas urusan awam dan mempercepatkan transformasi digital kerajaan justru kegagalan menyerahkan hasil berjumlah RM314 juta amatlah membimbangkan. Jumlah ini bukan kecil dan ia adalah hak rakyat yang sepatutnya digunakan untuk membiayai pelbagai keperluan pembangunan dan kebajikan masyarakat.  Apabila dua entiti ini gagal menunaikan tanggungjawab kewangan mereka rakyat mula mempersoalkan pengawasan dan mekanisme pemantauan yang ada di bawah kementerian berkenaan. Ia menimbulkan keraguan tentang sejauh mana kerajaan memastikan rakan kongsi yang dilantik mematuhi syarat perjanjian. Perkara yang lebih mendesak adalah ke mana perginya wang tersebut dan mengapa kelewatan ini dibiarkan berlaku sehingga ke tahap penggantungan perkhidmatan. Semua ini berlaku di bawah pengawasan m...
Post a Comment
Read more